Critical illness insurance provides a lump sum (tax free) payment to you if you are diagnosed with a covered condition such as heart attack, cancer, or stroke.
Critical illness policies often have a number of additional benefits you can purchase at an additional cost — called riders. The most prominent one is 'Return of Premium'. If you have a claim, the policy pays out the covered amount then expires. If you don't have a claim, and have a return of premium rider, then the policy (in the event of there being no claim) pays back all your premiums.
This sounds good — you either get paid out a claim, or if you don't, you get all your money back.
There are two common return of premium riders: Return of Premium at Death and Return of Premium at Expiry.
Return of Premium at Death
Return of Premium at Death is straightforward. If you pass away while the policy is in force (with no claim paid) then your beneficiaries receive the sum of your premiums.
Why would you want this? Well, it's almost always for emotional rather than financial reasons. The motivation is 'If I live, I get the benefit amount and if I die I get all my money back'. The problem with this argument is that it ignores interest — and over time, interest is worth far more than the sum of the premiums. I don't recommend Return of Premium at Death, save the cost of this rider and invest it somewhere else — you'll have more money in the end, and your money will be liquid (you won't have to die to access it).
Wawanesa Life, Co-operators and Foresters Financial all include Return of Premium at Death in their policies at no charge. Other companies charge for it.
Return of Premium at Expiry
Return of premium at expiry pays you the sum of your premiums at expiry. Very importantly — you have to keep the policy all the way to expiry. And of course, there's a cost for this benefit. What does NOT happen is that you purchase a Term 10 policy, cancel at the end of 10 years and get all your premiums back. For a Term 10 policy you'd have to keep the policy until age 75 to get all your premiums back. And the problem with that is that premiums by that age are very expensive. That leaves you in a conundrum: cancel because premiums are so high, or keep paying those high premiums in an effort to get back your premiums at 75? Prior to age 75 the amount of premium that would be returned is scaled with some companies so you only get back a % of your premiums, not the full amount. Other companies offer nothing prior to expiry.
Return of premium at expiry example
To show you the difference, here are the premiums for Canada Life for a $100,000 of Term 10 critical illness for a 40 year old male nonsmoker, both with and without the cost of the rider:
| Age | Without rider | With rider | Monthly cost of rider |
|---|---|---|---|
| 40 | $40.50 | $60.59 | $20.09 |
| 50 | $103.95 | $155.51 | $51.56 |
| 60 | $276.30 | $413.34 | $137.04 |
| 70 | $539.67 | $802.86 | $266.19 |
You can see the cost of the rider gets very expensive as you get older.
I recommend skipping this rider. It provides no real insurance benefit and your money will be better served investing on your own inside say an RRSP or TFSA.
