Critical illness insurance provides a lump sum (tax free) payment to you if you are diagnosed with a covered condition such as heart attack, cancer, or stroke.
Two questions that are vital to determining the best critical illness insurance for your situation — how much do I need, and what's the best type? I've covered the types in a separate article, here let's look at the amount of coverage.
Basic principles
Basic insurance principles suggest that to determine the amount of insurance coverage you should have, you should match the coverage to the actual financial loss. So if you develop a covered critical illness condition, where and how do you have a financial loss? Where do you 'lose money'? That will guide us to the coverage amount.
If you develop a covered condition, you are likely going to be off work for treatment and recovery. The timeframe could be weeks, months, or even a year. The financial loss here is your income — you're not earning an income for that period.
Disability insurance coverage
Now, you could have disability insurance — but that will generally have a 3 month waiting period where no benefits are provided (you're off work for three months with no pay). And beyond that it could still take your disability insurance company additional time to assess and pay. If you have disability insurance, you may have no income for 3–4 months, without disability coverage it could be many months beyond that.
So I often start with an estimate of your income from 6 months to a year.
Next, your spouse's income may be lost as well. If your spouse takes time off work to assist you with all your medical appointments, treatment, hospital visits, homecare, and so on, their lost income from taking time off work is not covered — disability insurance won't cover them. They'll likely have to take a leave of absence — in other words, 100% lost income for them.
So in addition to 6 months to a year of your income, I suggest adding to that number six months to a year of your spouse's income.
Summary of how much critical illness insurance
The total of those two give us a range of insurance that you might consider. Commonly our clients look at coverage of $100,000 (though coverage is available as low as $10,000 and as high as $2,000,000).
Two additional thoughts:
Recall at the beginning of this article I suggested that insurance principles require that we find the financial loss to insure — in this case that's your lost income and your spouse's lost income. Things such as family vacations and out of country medical treatment are not financial losses. I think it's unlikely you'll be in a condition to take a family vacation, and out of country medical treatments cost way more than the coverage most people insure themselves for, so I don't recommend including these factors in your assessment.
Secondly, you may consider that you can self-insure this, however that's unlikely for most of us. It may be possible to fund these expenses at the time of the loss. You can take on additional debt, or you can collapse your retirement savings — basically eat into your savings portfolio. The problem with this approach is that removal of $100,000 after-tax money from your retirement savings during your income earning years will dramatically reduce how much you have available at retirement — it can impact your retirement lifestyle. So even if you can weather these costs upfront, you're just deferring and increasing the impact of the loss. A low cost term 10 or term 20 critical illness policy can protect your savings and investment portfolio from this loss, and thus protect your retirement.
