Skip to main content

Types of life insurance

Term vs whole life insurance

Glenn Cooke

By Glenn Cooke, BMath, MMT

In insurance since 1986

Last reviewed:

Which is better? Term Insurance? Whole Life Insurance? What are the differences?

TermWhole Life
PremiumsCheaper short termCheaper over lifetime
As an investmentBetter if you have RRSP roomCan be better if RRSP’s/TFSA’s are maxed.

What is term life insurance?

Term life insurance is a life insurance policy where the premiums are level for an initial defined period of time known as the ‘term’. e.g. a 10 year term would have premiums that are level for 10 years, a 25 year term will have premiums that are level for 25 years.

At the end of the term, these policies ‘renew’ which means they stay in force, but premiums increase. So the defining attribute of a term life insurance policy is premiums that are inexpensive and level for a ‘term’, then increasingly expensive after that.

What is whole life insurance?

Whole life insurance generally has premiums that are level for life. In addition, if you cancel the policy after enough years have passed, there is a refund given back to you called a ‘cash surrender value’. Now there are some variations to this – you can compress your premiums down into 20 years instead of life (giving you a policy with no more premiums after 20 years), and you can get some policies where the coverage increases slowly over time. In addition, some policies have a lack of guarantees on some policy attributes. But for the purposes of this comparison, whole life insurance has two attributes – level premiums for life, and a cash surrender value if you cancel the policy before you die.

Term vs whole life insurance – premiums

Note that for identical coverage (e.g. $1MM of term insurance vs $1MM of whole life, both pay the same $1MM if you die) we have two different premium structures – term is cheap now, and gets excessively expensive later and whole life insurance has much higher premiums relatively speaking now, but is level for life and therefore cheaper than term in the long term.

Which is better? If you want life insurance for a defined period of time say 20 or 30 years, term life insurance will be cheaper than whole life. And when the premiums increase at the end of the term, it doesn’t matter because you’re cancelling – because you don’t need the insurance any more. So, if you need insurance over 10, 20 or 30 years, term wins.

However, if you want life insurance for life (burial expenses, or life insurance on children) then term doesn’t work anymore. It eventually becomes too expensive. Therefore a whole life policy with initially higher premiums but locked in level for life is better than term insurance in the long term. Looking for life insurance for life? Whole life is the winner here.

So really the decision here is, how long do you need the life insurance for? If you’re getting it for family purposes, generally we assume you need coverage roughly until retirement at which point the kids are self-sufficient, the mortgage is paid, and you have money saved for retirement. So you’re cancelling near retirement, and that’s term life insurance. If you’re getting life insurance for funeral expenses and to leave money to your beneficiaries, then you want coverage for life, and that’s whole life.

Term vs whole life insurance premium examples for a male nonsmoker, $1,000,000 monthly premiums

YearTerm PremiumsWhole Life Premiums
1-2086.401539
21-301162.801539
31-4035551539
41-458075.701539
46-6013325.401539

And this table shows us clearly how to choose – term insurance is far cheaper in the first 20-30 years but if we’re keeping coverage beyond that, whole life starts to become substantially cheaper.

Worth noting that in practice, you don’t have to do ‘either term or whole life’ and can in fact do some of both by layering some coverage types. For example, you could get $50,000 of whole life and $950,000 of Term 20. That will give you a total of $1,000,000 for the next 20 years then $50,000 from years 21 to the end of life. This structure covers you for a higher amount when you have mortgages, family needs and so on, and afterwards near retirement gives you a much lower amount but level for life.

Also worth noting, some term policies (and all of the term policies we quote on our website) are ‘convertible’. This means you can switch your term coverage over to a whole life in the future, without a medical exam, guaranteed. You should make sure that any term policy you select has this option.

Aside: see our note at the bottom of this article about variations of whole life that are even cheaper.

Term vs whole life insurance – investments

Term life insurance has no investment component, it’s basically pure life insurance. Whole life insurance has cash surrender values when you cancel. We can treat those cash surrender values as an investment i.e. we put the premiums in and get the cash value out and we can measure the investment return on the cash values. So we can, but should we?

The comparison of term vs whole life insurance here is called ‘buy term invest the difference’ and works like this. We take the whole life premiums and ‘invest’ in a whole life policy. At some point in the future we cancel the policy and receive our cash surrender values. Alternatively, we purchase a lower premium term life insurance policy and take the difference in premium and invest it ourselves. So who has more money – the term policy with investments? Or the whole life cash surrender value.

And the answer is, it depends on how your investments are taxed. If you are like most Canadians, and have access to RRSPs and TFSAs, then the winner is term life insurance. Investing in an RRSP and TFSA with reasonable assumptions will leave you with far more money in the end than a whole life cash value. So if you have room in your RRSPs and TFSAs, then term insurance is the clear winner. If you have maximized your RRSPs and TFSAs then you should have a good look at whole life insurance as an investment.

However, if you have maximized all your registered investments, then any remaining savings will be in some form of non-registered investments. And at that point (along with some additional tax planning), whole life cash values can beat what you can likely do on your own. And perhaps beat it by a wide margin. An example of this would be the Insured Retirement Plan strategy.

So which is better as an investment in term vs whole life insurance? If you have room in your RRSPs and TFSAs term is the clear winner. If you have maximized your RRPSs and TFSAs, then with some clever planning we can show you how whole life is the clear winner – it’ll make you more money than if you invest traditionally.

Summary – in the comparison between term vs whole life insurance, strictly for life insurance purposes, if you want life insurance for a period of time, then term insurance wins. If you want it for life, whole life wins. If you’re using life insurance for investment purposes and have RRSP or TFSA room, term insurance wins. If you don’t, whole life wins.

Aside: cheaper variations of whole life insurance

Whole life as described above is level premiums for life with a cash surrender value if you cancel. A lower cost alternative exists called Term 100. Term 100 life insurance has premiums that are level for life, but no cash values. It’s pure lifetime insurance – premiums and coverage, no investments. As a result, it has a lower premium than traditional whole life. If you’re seeking the lowest premium lifetime coverage, Term 100 is a policy you should evaluate. You can quote Term 100 premiums using our online life insurance quote system.

Ready to compare term life policies?

Quotes from 17 Canadian insurers. Premiums AND policy benefits — not just first-year price.

Get your term life quote

From 17 Canadian insurers · Instant

Gender
Smoker?
Date of birth

Your information stays private. Privacy policy.